• GBD videos on vimeo
  • subscribe : rss feed
  • Entry

    What’s in Skimmate ? | Ken Feldman Analyzes in Advanced Aquarist

    It’s absolutely disgusting, but what on earth is it? It’s a question that has been asked many times when discussing protein skimmers and more specifically the skimmate, or waste, that they produces in the collection cup. It has never been answered very well, but in the recent issue of Advanced Aquarist, Ken Feldman sheds some [...]

    It’s absolutely disgusting, but what on earth is it? It’s a question that has been asked many times when discussing protein skimmers and more specifically the skimmate, or waste, that they produces in the collection cup. It has never been answered very well, but in the recent issue of Advanced Aquarist, Ken Feldman sheds some light on the age old question. In his piece, Elemental Analysis of Skimmate: What Does a Protein Skimmer Actually Remove from Aquarium Water, he shows (for what we believe to be the first time) elemental analysis of skimmate. Surprisngly it did not contain as much organic carbon as one would have thought and contains a significant portion of inorganic particles. From it:

    In summary, the skimmer is pulling out a solid, water-insoluble mixture of compounds that consist by weight of (approximately):

    • 44 % of CaCO3
    • 5% of MgCO3
    • 11% of biogenic opal
    • 34% of organic material
    • 0.5% of phosphate

    Check out the full article over at AA and finally have an educated rebuttal to the question that gets asked time and time again when cleaning a collection cup–

    What’s that smell?!

    Related Posts

    1. Advanced Aquarist October Issue: Phosphorus, Regenerating GFO and Metasepia pfefferi
    2. April Advanced Aquarist Now Online
    3. Advanced Aquarist online magazine, January 2009 issue released!
    4. ATB Conical Waste Collector –Pairs Great With Cone Skimmers
    5. The Influence of Aquarium Filtration on DOC, Seen with UV 254 Analysis
    • http://reeflines.com/richievos Richie Vos

      44 % of CaCO3. That’s quite ironic given that we spend so much on expensive, powerful skimmers and also so much on Ca 2-part or Balling or reactors.

      This skimmer series of articles on advanced aquarist are wonderful. See also http://www.advancedaquarist.com/2010/1/aafeature

    • Deve

      Is it safe for compost?

    • http://aquadaily.com/ Aquadaily

      Hmm, nearly 50% inorganic. Maybe those Ecosystem guys were on to something… ;-)

    • http://aquadaily.com/ Aquadaily

      Hmm, nearly 50% inorganic. Maybe those Ecosystem guys were on to something… ;-)

    blog comments powered by Disqus